Untitled Document Bookstore Questions and Answers Site FAQ Links Bios CURRENTLY UNAVAILABLE


Ask Gordon Pape your question here!

Browse the Archives
1999 - 48 Questions
2000 - 247 Questions
2001 - 267 Questions
2002 - 258 Questions
2003 - 265 Questions
2004 - 255 Questions
2005 - 261 Questions
2006 - 210 Questions
2007 - 230 Questions
2008 - 231 Questions
2009 - 266 Questions
2010 - 148 Questions

Displaying 1 to 10 of 231 Records.
<Bought too many shares, lost money>
<Fed up with RRSPs>
<Wants to open an RRSP>
<“Tax-free” RRSP withdrawals>
<Trying to start over>
<Do they need RRSPs?>
<Needs RRSP money>
<Subprime meltdown – what to do?>
<Pension-splitting woes>
<Looking for retirement income>
GOTO PAGE: 1 10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  SHOW ALL 
 
Bought too many shares, lost money
Several years ago I opened a discount brokerage account and bought some shares. I only intended to purchase a small number – 200 shares – but while filling out the form online an extra zero was added and I ended up buying 2,000 shares instead. I didn't have the money and had to borrow money through my credit line.

Long story short, I still have those shares, however, they are now worthless. I feel stupid for holding on to them. My question is whether I can claim the interest paid on my credit line for the money I borrowed to purchase the shares. I still have a large outstanding amount on my credit line and still pay monthly interest because of it.

Now I want to sell all 2,000 shares. How do I claim this on my income tax as a capital loss? Can I claim a capital loss if I were to sell them now when I file my income tax in March? Is this procedure so complicated that I need a tax preparer or an accountant to do my income tax?

I also have other shares on which I have to declare a capital gain (this will not offset my capital loss). Is it true that I can offset the capital loss against the capital gains indefinitely until all the capital loss is covered? – L.T.

Too bad you didn’t notify the brokerage firm immediately of the purchase error. They might have been able to correct it. However, that’s now ancient history so let’s deal with your questions.

Yes, the interest on the loan is tax deductible, assuming that the money was used exclusively for investing. In fact, you can go back and claim for previous years as well. See the General Tax Guide for details on how to make changes to a previously-filed return. You can go back as far as 10 years.

Claiming a capital loss on your return is not complicated and you do not need an accountant. Buy a tax preparation software program, enter the numbers, and it will do the calculations for you.

However, if you sell the shares now you cannot claim the loss until you file your 2008 tax return. That won’t be until spring 2009. So you cannot use the loss this year to offset your capital gains. The good news is that you can retroactively apply any capital losses to the three previous tax years. Losses can also be carried forward indefinitely. – G.P.

Fed up with RRSPs
We have some money to invest. We have tried RRSPs in the past and became frustrated as we have never had any return whatsoever. We are our mid-thirties and would like something that provides some growth and stability any suggestions? – Scott and Melinda S.
My first suggestion is that you give RRSPs another chance. The fact that you made no profit in the past doesn’t mean there is anything inherently wrong with an RRSP. You simply made poor investment decisions, or received bad advice.

An RRSP is simply a tax-sheltered investment account. Your returns are predicated on what you invest in. It appears your RRSP money was invested in poorly-chosen securities, which is why it didn’t perform. It would have made no difference if those same securities had been held in a non-registered account – they still would have done badly.

So go back to the RRSP only this time try to be more selective in your investments. Start with a conservatively-managed balanced fund – one with a long history of steady returns and low risk. Some of the recommendations in my Mutual Funds Update newsletter that meet these criteria are Mackenzie Sentinel Income Fund (B units), Harbour Growth and Income Fund, Fidelity Canadian Asset Allocation Fund, TD Dividend Income Fund, and Signature Income and Growth Fund. Your financial advisor can help you make a selection.

Because of the tax-sheltering, you don’t need high returns to build a decent-size RRSP. If you invest $5,000 a year in a fund that generates an average annual gain of 7%, your plan will be worth almost $340,000 after 25 years.

Of course, I don’t advocate putting all your investment eggs in the same basket so over time you should add other funds to the mix. But you asked for a starting point, so there it is. – G.P.

Wants to open an RRSP
I am in the military and deal with TD Bank. I would like to invest in an RRSP. Which one should I choose? It will be long term but I only have $200 a month to invest. Hopefully you can shed some light on this for me as I know nothing about this matter. Any advice would be appreciated. – Mark M.
Since the amount you have to invest is relatively small, I suggest you set up an automatic contribution plan with your bank. They can handle all the arrangements and will arrange for $200 a month to be deposited to the RRSP account.

TD offers many good mutual funds that could be used to start your plan. I suggest one of their balanced or dividend funds – it’s a good idea to keep risk to a minimum in an RRSP. I’m sure a financial advisor at the bank will be happy to help you make a choice. – G.P.

“Tax-free” RRSP withdrawals
I recently turned 65 and would like to take advantage of the $2,000 tax-free RRSP withdrawal. Do I open a RRIF account to do this or just withdraw the $2,000 from my RRSP investments? If a RRIF is opened at age 65 is there a minimum withdrawal from age 65 to 71? – Keith M.
I believe you are a little confused about this. There is no such thing as a “tax-free RRSP withdrawal”. You must be thinking about the $2,000 pension income tax credit, at line 314 of the return. This allows you to claim a credit for the first $2,000 of eligible pension income. RRSP withdrawals do not qualify but RRIF payments made to people 65 and older are eligible.

So yes, you would need to convert some of your RRSP savings to a RRIF to take advantage of this. But you don’t have to convert the entire amount – just enough to enable you to withdraw $2,000 a year. You are allowed to have both a RRIF and an RRSP until age 71.

Once the RRIF is set up, minimum withdrawals must be made every year. But if you take my advice and keep the RRIF small, that should not create a tax problem. – G.P.

Trying to start over
My question is should I buy a house or invest in RRSP? My husband and I have done all the wrong things since our marriage 30 years ago. We have been discharged from bankruptcy for six years now. We have no savings and don't own a home (lost it through our bankruptcy). I have started saving $200 every two weeks from my pay. I would like to buy a house with no deposit once I save for the legal expenses. Our rental unit is too small.

Am I making a mistake? Isn't paying rent of $1,000 a month a waste of money? I am 49 years old and my husband is 55. Are we too old to be thinking of buying a house? – P.D.P.

You have been through some difficult financial times, no doubt about it. I commend your efforts to start saving again and to rebuild your assets.

My advice is to forget about buying a house for now. Although it technically can be done with the use of mortgage insurance, I doubt you would find any company that would finance a mortgage with no down payment, especially given what has happened with the subprime market in the U.S.

Instead, I suggest you go the RRSP route for the time being. Based on the figures you quote, you should be able to contribute $5,200 over the next year ($200 x 26 payments). If you invest the money carefully, within a few years your plan should be worth well over $20,000.

At that point, you can start thinking seriously about becoming a homeowner. You can borrow up to $20,000 from the RRSP interest-free to use as a down payment, under the Home Buyers’ Plan. If your husband can set up an RRSP as well, he could also borrow $20,000, for a total of $40,000 between you. Assuming you choose a modest house, you should have no problem obtaining a mortgage at that stage. Good luck. – G.P.

Follow-up: Recently, I was asked whether it was better to pay down the mortgage or contribute to an RRSP. In my reply, I said I was not aware of any on-line calculators that could help make this decision easier. A reader, Wade L., was kind enough to send along the following link. Try it out.

Click Here

Do they need RRSPs?
My husband and I both contribute to defined benefits retirement plans through our place of employment. We also have a primary residence with a mortgage and an investment property that we rent out (and use to help write down our taxes). We do not have any RRSPs (but do have an RESP for the kids’ education). I want to focus my finances on paying off the mortgages to help fund retirement rather than buying RRSPs. What do you think of this strategy? – Eva V., Vancouver
You are very fortunate. These days, defined benefit pension plans are increasingly hard to find. The fact that both you and your husband belong to such plans puts you well ahead of most other people when it comes to retirement savings.

In these circumstances, RRSPs do not have to be a top priority. However, before you make a final decision on a strategy, I suggest you do some projections. See if you can get estimates as to how much income you will each receive from the pension plans at retirement and match that against your anticipated expenses. There are worksheets to help you do this in my book The Retirement Time Bomb. You may also want to make use of the RRSP/mortgage calculator at Click Here

Also, remember that you can have your cake and eat it too. If you have any RRSP room (check your last notices of assessments from the Canada Revenue Agency) you could make contributions and then use the refund generated to pay down the mortgage. – G.P.

Needs RRSP money
I was terminated from my employment a couple of years ago and I have been given the option of cashing in my non locked in company pension or put it into a RRSP. I decided to put it into a RRSP just a month ago and now I find that I am in need of the funds and have to cash it in. The amount is $7,200. I was wondering what kind of taxes will be withheld when I cash it in and also what I might have to pay come April of 2009. I am on long-term disability through private insurance and am also on CPP disability. – A.D.P.
Are you sure the money is not locked in? That is very unusual if it comes from a pension plan. If that is in fact the case, there will be withholding tax of 20% on a $7,200 withdrawal, unless you live in Quebec where the figure would be 30%. You will be taxed on the money at your marginal rate when you file your 2008 tax return, with credit given for the tax already withheld. I have no way of knowing what your marginal rate will be since you did not provide an estimate of your total income. – G.P.
Subprime meltdown – what to do?
With the current financial climate, slowing U.S. economy, and subprime meltdown, what's an investor to do? My husband and are in our mid-50s and don't want to risk our investments so we are sticking with boring GICs (found rates in the 4.6% range) for 1-2 years. What are your thoughts on the state of the economy and should we as investors stay on the sidelines and wait for the subprime mess to clean itself out? Also, how safe are our Canadian banks from this subprime mess? Do you see any of them going under? – Wendy and John
To answer your last question first, it is unlikely in the extreme that any major Canadian bank would go under. All are very well capitalized and if any one of them were faced with that kind of situation, the Government of Canada would move quickly to allow it to be taken over by one of the other major players in the industry. You may recall that’s what happened when Royal Trust ran into trouble several years ago and was eventually bought out by Royal Bank.

However, that doesn’t mean the share prices of the banks aren’t vulnerable and in fact CIBC, which is the one most exposed to tainted subprime paper, is down 38% from its 2007 high.

What to do in these circumstances? Well, there is nothing wrong with your boring GICs. Better boring than losing, I always say. If you want to aim for better returns, buy some bonds or bond funds, especially those that focus on government issues. Bonds have done very well in the past few months and should continue to outperform stocks if, as expected, interest rates continue to drop in the first half of 2008. – G.P.

Pension-splitting woes
My husband is 63 and retired. I am 51. He has a small CPP and no other income. He has a small spousal RRSP to which I contribute. I have a much larger RRSP and a locked-in RRSP. Am I correct that any pension income splitting (from my RRSP after it is converted into RRIF) will be allowed only after I turn 65, not my husband? (There is no tax advantage for him to split with me.) It seems unfair that we can't benefit from the pension income splitting because of our age gap.

I learned that to take advantage of the $2,000 pension credit, my husband should convert $2,000 of RRSP money into a RRIF, withdraw from the RRIF, and transfer the tax credit to my tax return. However, once he's started a RRIF, can I still continue to contribute to the spousal RRSP to minimize my taxes? Or should I forgo the $2,000 pension credit and claim the spousal RRSP deduction only? I have sufficient RRSP room.

Do most financial institutions allow a partial conversion of RRSP to RRIF? – L.W., South Surrey, BC

You are correct in regard to the pension-splitting rules. Unfair though it may seem, RRIF withdrawals are not eligible for pension splitting until the annuitant reaches age 65.

There’s better news regarding the pension credit. There is no law against a person having both an RRSP and a RRIF at the same time, as long as the person is no older than age 71. And your financial institution should permit partial RRSP conversions. However, I suggest that your husband shift more than $2,000 into the small RRIF for this purpose. If he collapses the plan each year, he’ll have to go through all the hassle of setting up a new one 12 months later.

One other point. As far as RRIF withdrawals are concerned, the pension credit can only be claimed at age 65 so he’ll have to wait two years to do this. – G.P.

Looking for retirement income
My wife and I are looking for a monthly income in our retirement next year. What are the advantages and disadvantage of putting our investment of $125,000 RRSP and $325,000 in mutual funds into a monthly income fund? We also will have a combined net pension of $3,800 per month. - N and J, Oshawa ON
There are several good monthly income funds available but I would not recommend putting all your money in only one of them. They vary as to management style, risk level, and performance. For example, the BMO Monthly Income Fund is very conservatively managed so the risk is lower. But the three-year average annual compound rate of return of 8% is well below that of the CIBC, Fidelity, RBC, and TD monthly income entries.

Tax is another factor you need to consider, since most of your money is in a non-registered account. For example, about half the payments from the RBC Monthly Income Fund were fully taxable last year whereas less than 20% of the distributions paid by the BMO fund attracted tax at the top rate.

As you can see, there are several variables to consider. You may want to seek the help of a financial advisor to sort through them all. – G.P.

GOTO PAGE: 1 10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  SHOW ALL 
 

© 1996-2010 Gordon Pape Enterprises Ltd. Please e-mail us for permission before reproducing or redistributing any part of the information contained within.
All material on this site and in any transmissions and publications relating to it is copyright Gordon Pape Enterprises Ltd. and may not be reproduced in whole or in part in any form without written consent. All recommendations are based on information that is believed to be reliable. However, results are not guaranteed and the publishers and distributers of any information and/or recommendations reproduced here or transmitted from this site assume no liability whatsoever for any material losses that may occur. Readers are advised to consult a professional financial advisor before making any investment decisions. Gordon Pape and/or members of his family may hold positions in securities mentioned on this site or in publications associated with it. No compensation for recommending particular securities or financial advisors is solicited or accepted.

Email The Webmaster | Email Customer Service